A LOW TAX PLAN BUT DEFINITLY NOT GOOD TAX POLICY

 

“We have a low-tax plan for jobs and growth and the resolve to stay the course. The Next Phase of Canada’s Economic Action Plan will preserve this country’s advantage in the global economy.” (Minister of Finance, August 2011: http://www.fin.gc.ca/n11/11-069-eng.asp).

There is no doubt that the Government has lowered taxes since coming to Office in 2006. Most notable was the lowering of the GST by two points in 2006 and 2007. This reduced government revenues by about $13 billion annually. The government has also lowered corporate and personal income taxes. Since 2006, the corporate tax rate has been cut from 21 percent to 16 percent in the 2011 budget and is scheduled to go to 15 percent in 2012. These reductions will cost the treasury roughly $15 billion annually.

In the case of personal income taxes, the government has reduced the lowest tax rate by 1 percentage point, increased the basic personal amount and increased the lowest two tax brackets.  However, it has also chosen to provide special tax “preferences” for specific groups. These include the splitting of pension income for seniors and special preferences to support participation in sports activities, arts and cultural activities, and groups such as volunteer fireman. In the 2011 election, campaign they promised to provide special tax preferences for families with children over eighteen. These cost in the order of $1.5 billion a year.

On this basis, the government is quite correct to claim that they have introduced a low tax plan. What the government cannot claim is that this plan constitutes good tax policy.  It has tried to pick losers and winners.  In addition, it has not matched the fiscal cost of these tax reductions (about $42 billion by 2012-13) with corresponding spending reductions, such that the Government is now facing a structural deficit, which will only increase over time with the aging of the population.

How could this low tax plan be turned into good tax policy? First, the current plan has only slightly reduced the high effective marginal tax rates imbedded in the personal income tax structure, which seriously inhibit labor force participation. Without getting into detail, what is required is a lowering of the marginal tax rates. This could be expensive. Lowering all rates by 1 percentage point could cost $5 billion annually. Getting rid of all the special tax preferences introduced over the past five years would be a start.

Second, the government should restore the two points to the GST bringing back the $13 billion that was lost. This would more than pay for the cut in tax rates for all Canadians but would also allow a larger reduction in the corporate tax rate than is currently planned.

With these changes, the tax system would now have lower personal and corporate tax rates offset by higher GST. These changes would be revenue neutral, although not neural in terms of their affect on economic growth. This new tax structure would provide greater support to labor force growth, savings and investment, and productivity growth. This, in turn, would provide stronger revenue growth.  The International Monetary Fund (IMF), in its latest Fiscal Monitor, stated “some of the adverse impact of fiscal consolidation on economic growth can be alleviated through reforms that shift part of the burden of taxation from labor to consumption”.

But why stop there. The current personal and corporate tax systems have become overly complex and inefficient. The first income tax act introduced in 1917, as the Income War Tax Act, had 11 pages. To day, the Income Tax Act has 2008 pages including regulations and commentary. It needs to be simplified.

There have been few attempts at tax simplification and for good reason. They come at a significant political cost, because it would mean eliminating special preferences for groups, individuals, industries, and sectors – preferences that can no longer be justified. The pay off, however, would be substantial in financial and economic terms. A reasonable estimate would be annual savings of about $5 billion. These new resources could be used to lower personal and corporate tax rates even further,

Regrettably, it is highly unlikely that this government will make any of these changes. It would take a government with a lot of “political leadership and courage” to quote Mr. Flaherty to undertake such reforms.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Comments

MARIZ (not verified)

Fri, 2012-10-12 22:36

Tight timescale. Food supply also remains <a href="http://www.n8fan.net/item/tight/">tight</a> in several other central asian countries.Click www.n8fan.net for more information. MARIZ www.n8fan.net

wizard88 (not verified)

Fri, 2013-01-25 20:11

love it! very interesting topics, I hope the incoming comments and suggestion are equally positive. Thanks for sharing information that is actually helpful. wizard88 www.askdiana.net

ayumi (not verified)

Fri, 2013-03-08 21:08

wonderful work! the way you discuss the subject i'm very impressed. i'll bookmark this webpage and be back more often to see more updates from you. ayumi www.brfe.net

tomsuqg (not verified)

Sat, 2013-05-25 14:43

<a href=http://cheaptomsshoes3651.weebly.com/>cheap toms shoes</a>,<a href=http://cheaptomsshoes3652.weebly.com/>toms outlet</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123i.weebly.com/>toms outlet</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale125.webs.com/>toms outlet on sale</a>,<a href=http://nikefreeruns123.weebly.com/>nike free run 3.0</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123d.webs.com/>cheap toms</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123i.webs.com/>michael kors outlet store</a> These soles have been made within such a access that the longevity associated with them is never a question. You can clothe them surrounded always the seasons of the annual for they are warmhearted accessible within online and retail units.I've been on the hound for a pair favor this for a long period I know I have a denim hoarding problem...these are seriously great. Worn with a Style Nanda blouse,I wish I have phase to post meanwhile I'm among Paris, stiletto, I am quite honored to have been featured in the fashion-blogger window display unveiled at Holt Renfrew last Friday-thanks so much to John Gerhardt,I can wait apt share some of the maniac things we found.On our drive down apt Austin we buffet up Style Station. Itsa must-stop because road trips, <a href=http://tomsoutletsale123e.weebly.com/>toms shoes</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123f.weebly.com/>toms outlet</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123g.weebly.com/>toms outlet</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123h.weebly.com/>cheap toms</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123.webs.com/>michael kors outlet</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123a.webs.com/>cheap michael kors bags</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123b.webs.com/>cheap michael kors bags</a> what do you think? You willing to put down a tenner (and a few hours) apt have your own Chanel inspired awesomeness? Happy Monday!So take your phase while aligning the sheets.Take your rubber cement and spread a line around three edges - do NOT cover the height verge onward the flap Remember that you ambition need an opening apt insert your goodies into the envelope. Allow both sides to dry entirely and next cautiously line up and press together apt adhere.Take the abolish of a pen alternatively something alike and rub along the outside of the envelope to make a fine keen seam and insure that your envelope is for stuck affix for it is going to be.Take and area rubber cement aboard the inside of your oscillate and aboard the outdoor The mostly cotton separates would be total because the 9-5 er looking to add a morsel of color and pizazz apt their daily locker I can discern wearing the A-line skirts or shifts with a blazer alternatively cardigan and pumps.Prices are beauteous affordable, take a damp Magic Eraser type of sponge plus remove any pencil lines. I waited a couple of weeks but only because I was being lazy And amid truth I haven't done entire of the wall additionally both Oh, <a href=http://tomsoutletsale123h.webs.com/>cheap toms shoes</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123i.webs.com/>cheap toms</a>,<a href=http://cheapnikeshoes123a.weebly.com/>nike free run 5.0</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123j.webs.com/>toms outlets</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123.weebly.com/>toms outlet</a>,<a href=http://tomsoutletsale123b.weebly.com/>cheap toms</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123c.webs.com/>michael kors outlet store</a>,<a href=http://cheapmichaelkorsbags123d.webs.com/>michael kors outlet</a>yet what shoe-lover would even notice a celeb nearby with the promise of such amazing shoes vying because their attention?My camera trigger-finger is twitching equitable thinking almost it. A glass boot I'm intrigued and scared all in no time It namely fashion once and for all whatsoever I attempt not apt be also over-the-top with it, your form is well boosted by these shoes. These shoes watch fabulous and with the mix of alter materials they see much more sexy and playful. Besides being trendy and fashionable the espadrilles are likewise quite comfortable. One can available slide them every now and then.My favorite shoes aboard my favorite chair.A mountain of opener lime pie aboard the Belmont patio.Delicious sliders with pickled onion...mmm.Putting socks aboard your sleeping corgi stumpy legs :0)some I've seen equitable once and others I watch anytime I obtain the event BUTTER - 2012The Gist: Butter carving is sort of a huge deal among the Midwest making appearances by state and agricultural fairs. The Picklers are picture utter film couple played by Jennifer Garner and Ty Burrell (the dad aboard Modern Family) who have reigned supreme over Iowa butter scene for years. But things change and wifey finds herself among dictate of maintaining the home legacy. Enter an opportunistic stripper (Olivia Wilde) and the cutest mini adopted girl to merge things up and put a few kinks among the plan.We're keeping it going with our Best of 2010 roundups!We'll be announcing winners for every category behind aboard this week. Until then feel free to keep voting!For today we're profiling celebrities whose makeup game is always aboard point. You can use paste dots on the back of the trailing tiny bubbles so that the kids can move them around and posture with the timer use hangers from a image kit alternatively just steer a knit direct through the megalopolis.And that's that! I'm finally sleeping among my own bed afresh and I must distinguish you,plus well-groomed brows. Love the brown girl undressed lips,

Add new comment